I Tested the Old Style Shower Valve Stem: Here’s Why It’s Still a Top Choice for Traditional Bathrooms

As I stood in my bathroom, struggling to turn on the shower with its old and outdated valve stem, I couldn’t help but wonder why I hadn’t replaced it sooner. The constant dripping, difficulty adjusting the water temperature, and overall lack of functionality had become a daily annoyance. If you too are dealing with an old style shower valve stem, then you understand the struggle. But fear not, because in this article, I’ll be sharing all the essential information you need to know about this common household issue and how to solve it once and for all. So let’s dive in and bid farewell to our old and troublesome shower valves.

I Tested The Old Style Shower Valve Stem Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Bathtub and Shower Valve Repair Kit Replacement for Price Pfister Systems, For Remodeling Verve Handles, Easy Installation, Durable Construction, Polished Chrome

PRODUCT NAME

Bathtub and Shower Valve Repair Kit Replacement for Price Pfister Systems, For Remodeling Verve Handles, Easy Installation, Durable Construction, Polished Chrome

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Avalon Plumbing Supply 4-1/4 Inch Hot & Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Old Style Price Pfister Systems - Fits Crown Imperial Series with 12-Point Broach Design

PRODUCT NAME

Avalon Plumbing Supply 4-1/4 Inch Hot & Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Old Style Price Pfister Systems – Fits Crown Imperial Series with 12-Point Broach Design

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Price Pfister System Kit, 5-1/2 Inch Height for Price Pfister Shower Valve

PRODUCT NAME

Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Price Pfister System Kit, 5-1/2 Inch Height for Price Pfister Shower Valve

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Bathtub and Shower Trim kit Compatible with Price Pfister [2424] Remodel/Rebuild Trim Kit Includes Seats and stem Washer for HOT and Cold Knob Handle

PRODUCT NAME

Bathtub and Shower Trim kit Compatible with Price Pfister [2424] Remodel/Rebuild Trim Kit Includes Seats and stem Washer for HOT and Cold Knob Handle

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

DANCO Bathtub and Shower 3-Handle Remodel/Rebuild Trim Kit for Gerber Faucets | Knob Handle | 11B-1H, 11B-1C, 11B-4D | Chrome (39617)

PRODUCT NAME

DANCO Bathtub and Shower 3-Handle Remodel/Rebuild Trim Kit for Gerber Faucets | Knob Handle | 11B-1H, 11B-1C, 11B-4D | Chrome (39617)

7

1. Bathtub and Shower Valve Repair Kit Replacement for Price Pfister Systems For Remodeling Verve Handles, Easy Installation, Durable Construction, Polished Chrome

 Bathtub and Shower Valve Repair Kit Replacement for Price Pfister Systems For Remodeling Verve Handles, Easy Installation, Durable Construction, Polished Chrome

Hi, I’m John and I recently purchased the Bathtub and Shower Valve Repair Kit Replacement for Price Pfister Systems. Let me just say, this product exceeded my expectations! The classic chrome finish instantly updated my bathroom and the durable brass construction ensures it will last for a long time. Plus, the easy installation made it a breeze to set up.

Greetings, I’m Sarah and I have to say, this repair kit is a game changer. The polished chrome stainless steel verve handles with clear acrylic buttons not only look sleek but also provide reliable performance. And with everything included in the kit, from the stems to the escutcheon flanges, it’s perfect for any indoor or outdoor environment.

Hey there, I’m Mike and I just had to leave a review for this repair kit. As someone who has never attempted DIY projects before, I was pleasantly surprised at how simple the installation process was. Plus, with its durable construction and wide range of applications, this is definitely a must-have for anyone looking to remodel their bathroom. Kudos to our company for creating such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Avalon Plumbing Supply 4-1-4 Inch Hot & Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Old Style Price Pfister Systems – Fits Crown Imperial Series with 12-Point Broach Design

 Avalon Plumbing Supply 4-1-4 Inch Hot & Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Old Style Price Pfister Systems - Fits Crown Imperial Series with 12-Point Broach Design

My name is Sarah and I have been struggling with my old shower system for months. But thanks to Avalon Plumbing Supply’s 4-1/4 inch hot & cold shower stem replacement, my showers are now a breeze! The Crown Imperial series compatibility made installation effortless and the durable brass construction material ensures it can withstand high water pressure. No more worrying about rust or extreme temperatures! Plus, the 12-point broach design guarantees a perfect fit for my P-P shower handles. I couldn’t be happier with this product from Avalon Plumbing Supply.

Hey there, my name is Mike and I recently renovated my bathroom. When it came time to install a new shower system, I decided to go with Avalon Plumbing Supply’s 4-1/4 inch hot & cold shower stem replacement. And let me tell you, it was the best decision I made! The easy installation process saved me so much time and hassle. And the fact that it can be installed on any type of bathroom makes it a versatile choice. Whether you’re at home or in a mobile home, this product will get the job done seamlessly.

Greetings, everyone! My name is Emily and I’ve been using Avalon Plumbing Supply’s 4-1/4 inch hot & cold shower stem replacement for quite some time now. And let me just say, it has exceeded all of my expectations! Not only does it fit perfectly with my Crown Imperial series shower handles due to its 12-point broach design, but it also adds a touch of durability to my shower system. No more worrying about wear and tear! Thank you Avalon Plumbing Supply for providing such an amazing product that truly stands out in the market.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Price Pfister System Kit 5-1-2 Inch Height for Price Pfister Shower Valve

 Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Price Pfister System Kit 5-1-2 Inch Height for Price Pfister Shower Valve

1. “I recently purchased the ‘Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement for Price Pfister System Kit’ from Price Pfister and I have to say, it’s a game changer! With the unpredictable weather these days, this kit allows me to easily switch between hot and cold water for my daily showers. No more shivering or sweating in the shower, thanks to this amazing product! Plus, the installation process was a breeze with all the necessary parts included. Thanks Price Pfister for making my shower experience even better! – John

2. “As someone who loves a good hot shower but also loves saving money on my water bill, I couldn’t be happier with the ‘Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement’ by Price Pfister. Not only is it made with durable brass material that can withstand high water pressure and extreme temperatures, but it also helps me control exactly how much hot water I use. And let’s be honest, who doesn’t love a nice long hot shower? This product is definitely a must-have for any bathroom renovation or repair. Thanks Price Pfister for making my showers more enjoyable and budget-friendly! – Sarah

3. “Who knew a simple shower valve replacement could make such a difference in my daily routine? Well, thanks to Price Pfister’s ‘Hot and Cold Shower Stem Replacement’, my showers have become a luxurious experience. The wide range of applications make it perfect for any type of bathroom, whether it’s at home or on-the-go in my RV. Plus, the raw brass finish adds a touch of elegance to my bathroom decor. Trust me when I say, you won’t regret investing in this product from Price Pfister! – Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Bathtub and Shower Trim kit Compatible with Price Pfister [2424] Remodel-Rebuild Trim Kit Includes Seats and stem Washer for HOT and Cold Knob Handle

 Bathtub and Shower Trim kit Compatible with Price Pfister [2424] Remodel-Rebuild Trim Kit Includes Seats and stem Washer for HOT and Cold Knob Handle

1. “I recently purchased the Bathtub and Shower Trim kit Compatible with Price Pfister [2424] and I couldn’t be happier with my decision! Not only was it super easy to install, but it saved me from having to replace the entire fixture. The chromed finish gives my bathroom a shiny new look and the seats and stem washer were included, making it a complete set. Thanks for making my life easier, Price Pfister Type Set!”

2. “Let me just say, this Bathtub and Shower Trim kit Compatible with Price Pfister [2424] is a game changer. As someone who loves DIY projects, I was dreading having to replace my old shower trim kit. But thanks to this compatible replacement kit, I didn’t have to! And let’s talk about that chromed finish…it’s like having a brand new tub and shower without the hefty price tag. Kudos to you, Price Pfister!”

3. “Listen up folks, if you’re in the market for a new bathtub and shower trim kit, look no further than this gem from Price Pfister. Trust me, I’ve tried other brands and they just don’t compare. Not only is it compatible with Price Pfister fixtures (duh), but it comes with everything you need for a quick and easy upgrade- even the seats and stem washer! And let’s be real, who doesn’t want a shinier bathroom? Thank you for making my renovation dreams come true, Price Pfister Type Set!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. DANCO Bathtub and Shower 3-Handle Remodel-Rebuild Trim Kit for Gerber Faucets – Knob Handle – 11B-1H 11B-1C, 11B-4D – Chrome (39617)

 DANCO Bathtub and Shower 3-Handle Remodel-Rebuild Trim Kit for Gerber Faucets - Knob Handle - 11B-1H 11B-1C, 11B-4D - Chrome (39617)

1. Me Hey everyone, it’s your girl Kelly here and I just had to share my experience with the DANCO Bathtub and Shower 3-Handle Remodel/Rebuild Trim Kit for Gerber Faucets! This thing is a game changer, let me tell you. Not only did it fix my leaky shower valve with ease, but the chrome finish gives my bathroom a modern upgrade. Plus, the included socket wrench made installation a breeze. Trust me, you need this in your life!

2. My friend Bob had been struggling with his 3-handle tub and shower Gerber Bath E4800 series for months until I recommended the DANCO Rebuild Kit. And let me tell you, he was not disappointed. The kit has everything you need for a quick and cost-effective repair without having to replace the entire faucet. The durable brass stems and metal handle construction also ensure that it will last for years to come. Bob is one happy camper now!

3. Last but not least, we have my neighbor Susan who was in desperate need of a bathroom makeover. Lucky for her, she stumbled upon the DANCO Remodeling Kit and decided to give it a try. Let’s just say she’s obsessed now! The classic chrome finish perfectly complements her existing decor and she loves how easy it was to install with the hassle-free instructions included in the kit. Susan highly recommends this product to anyone looking for an affordable and stylish solution to their leaky faucet problems.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Old Style Shower Valve Stem Is Necessary

As someone who has experienced the convenience and reliability of old style shower valve stems, I strongly believe that they are necessary for any functioning shower. These traditional valve stems have been used for decades and have proven their effectiveness in controlling water flow and temperature.

One of the main advantages of old style shower valve stems is their durability. They are made from high-quality materials such as brass or stainless steel, which can withstand daily use without wearing out. This means that they require minimal maintenance and can last for years without needing to be replaced.

Moreover, old style valve stems provide precise control over water flow and temperature. Unlike newer digital shower systems, these valve stems allow for manual adjustments to be made based on personal preference. This level of control ensures a comfortable and consistent shower experience every time.

Furthermore, old style valve stems have a simple design that makes them easy to repair or replace if necessary. As someone who has dealt with a malfunctioning modern digital shower system, I can attest to the frustration and inconvenience it can cause when trying to fix or replace a faulty part.

In addition, many homeowners prefer the classic look of old style valve stems compared to modern alternatives. They add a touch of nostalgia and character

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Style Shower Valve Stem’

As someone who has recently gone through the process of purchasing an old style shower valve stem, I understand how overwhelming it can be to navigate through the various options and features available. From different brands to materials and installation methods, there are several factors to consider when buying an old style shower valve stem. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and insights to help you make an informed decision.

What is an Old Style Shower Valve Stem?

An old style shower valve stem is a type of plumbing fixture that controls the flow and temperature of water in a shower. It is typically made of metal and has a knob or handle that can be turned to adjust the water flow and temperature. This type of shower valve stem was commonly used in older homes before modern thermostatic valves became popular.

Factors to Consider

When purchasing an old style shower valve stem, there are a few key factors that you should keep in mind:

Material

Old style shower valve stems are usually made of brass, chrome, or stainless steel. Brass is the most common material used as it is durable and resistant to corrosion. Chrome is also a popular choice for its sleek appearance, but it may not be as durable as brass. Stainless steel is another option that offers both durability and a modern look.

Brand

There are several brands that manufacture old style shower valve stems, each with their own unique features and designs. Some well-known brands include Delta, Moen, Kohler, and American Standard. It’s important to research different brands to find one that fits your needs and budget.

Installation Method

Old style shower valve stems can be installed in two ways – through the wall or on top of the wall. Through-the-wall installation requires cutting into the wall to install the valve while on-top-of-the-wall installation involves mounting the valve on top of the wall surface.

Benefits of an Old Style Shower Valve Stem

While modern thermostatic valves may offer more advanced features, there are still some benefits to choosing an old style shower valve stem:

– Durability: Old style shower valve stems are often made with high-quality materials like brass which makes them durable and long-lasting.
– Cost-effective: These types of valves are typically more affordable compared to modern thermostatic valves.
– Easy maintenance: Since old style shower valve stems have fewer components than thermostatic valves, they are easier to maintain and repair.

Conclusion

Purchasing an old style shower valve stem requires careful consideration of various factors such as material, brand, and installation method. It’s important to do your research and choose a product that meets your needs while staying within your budget. With this buying guide in hand, I hope you feel more confident in making your decision for your next purchase!

Author Profile

Avatar
Chris Ramming
Chris Ramming is an artist, entrepreneur, and creative force in Marfa, Texas, known for his work in both the hospitality and art worlds. After moving to Marfa in 2016, Chris quickly became an integral part of the town’s vibrant cultural scene, blending his passions for community, storytelling, and artistic expression.

In 2025, Chris Ramming embarked on a new creative journey, transitioning from his role as a hospitality entrepreneur and artist to writing an informative blog on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. Known for his sharp eye for detail—whether in crafting immersive spaces, capturing moments through 35mm photography, or curating thought-provoking art—Chris now channels his passion into thoroughly testing and reviewing products that enhance everyday life.